Saturday, December 20, 2014

All American Boyz New York 2

7 Million in New York for the parade. I have gone back to the largest ever parade event in World and North American- OK then New York –Empire State History not because on the face of it there appears to be any or much connection to The Holocaust of European Jews in the early years of the 1940 decade- But underlying our thoughts we have been considering American Hero’s –All American Boys- Worshipped and obeyed men who lead millions and controlled millions –the most powerful people of a past century to see- well why New York? All these people are products of New York’s education, environment, political aspirations and success- yet literally at times they have- these men- control over the destinies of nations –the direction of the world… Oh well Empire State Rules the World OK! So humor me here as I wander off from the IBM and the Holocaust story to look at something unrelated but the product of the very same decades of the first half of the 20th century- As we consider Greatest Ever US military General- Douglas MacArthur responsible as you may well know for the largest and most catastrophic US military defeats- Firstly to Japan in their anyone could have predicted they would come- decimation of the American military stronghold in the Philippines December 1941. And then as we remember every time we Celebrate Weeping Thanksgiving- the largest ever US military defeat –Thanksgiving 1950- A MacArthur engineered disaster! ‘Truman and his advisors expected an explosion but it was much worse than any of them had imagined. Huge crowds turned out for MacArthur everywhere. It began in Tokyo where as he departed, quarter of a million Japanese many of them weeping, most of them waving small Japanese and American flags, lined the streets. Giant crowds gathered in Hawaii where he landed after midnight, and an ever larger one met him in San Francisco again after midnight- a crowd so immense that the security people could not hold them back. When eventually he came to New York for a tickertape parade, it was said that 7 million people turned out, twice as many as Eisenhower returning victorious from World War 2….. It was a last hurrah for a great hero of WW2, combined with a powerful protest by a nation that did not enjoy it’s new superpower status. It was produced by almost equal parts of love and anger. It was powerful stuff. It was also political- not acclaimed of the crowds, the millions of Americans who rallied to MacArthur’s cause, which they saw as something simpler than it was, but the challenge of the Republican right. At first the general had it all his own way… Those who did not see what he saw, those who did not want to use all of America’s force in Korea, were guilty of appeasement…. Those who would ‘appease Red China’… ‘appeasement begets new and bloodier war’. Those who thought we lacked the forces to hold the Communists in both Europe and Asia were wrong… He had wanted to use the 600,000 Nationalist soldiers on Taiwan but was not granted them… I am closing my fifty two years of military service. When I joined the Army even before the turn of the century it was the fulfillment of all my boyish hopes and dreams… Old soldiers never die; they just fade away- the old soldier who tried to do his duty as God gave him light to see that duty. Good bye’ p607-609 The Coldest Winter David Halberstam Macmillian 2007

1 comment:

  1. I am riding a high wire here attempting to speak at the same time to the most Right Wing American you can ever meet and the most Left Wing- because I genuinely love and respect both- and some of them love and follow a Jew. New Zealand in military adventures- our army have always been suspicious of big bold Imperial Leaders such as MacArthur. We have learnt in military conflict to form our own opinion- to secure our position and to fight in the basic six man unit where anyone of those in that unit can and will assume command if anyone goes down. Reading Coldest Winter you can see that those who came out- and led men out of the Thanksgiving 1950 trap which MacArthur deliberately set up for the US Army and USA on the Korean/China border- Those who emerged alive and then went onto to conclude the Korean War as it's leaders- were those who had assumed the leadership which under MacArthur as a controlling Cult Leader was missing- distrusted that MacArthur Leadership. That distrust of Imperial Leadership- American or before that British is basic to the success of the New Zealand Army in combat. In WW2 we always had the option of our top general being able to phone home to our Prime Minister for advice... In other words if MacArthur or any other Supreme Leader told us to do things which were politically and militarily -stupid; We could and did -phone home and our PM said- I Agree Don't Do it! What happened with MacArthur is that he joined a powerful group of men who seeing Hitler and Hirtohito defeated immediately want to fight the war Hitler had not won-Communism! And when China in 1950 went Communist- with USA having nuclear weapons it appeared to some easy to win that war. The untold- Well do read 'The Coldest Winter' Untold story of US military collapse in North Korea is why we should not trust MacArthur as a Cult Leader. Millions died unnecessary deaths and suffering as a result of his decisions. Respect him as a man- Yes but don't as do some Chinese at a nearby Chinese Temple- they literally worship as a god! No joke! MacArthur! Finally I am big on- Location. This week Sony pulled a movie making a death threat against the ;leader of North Korea. In 1984 Paul Wolfawitz made a similar death threat against our leader David Lange. While in the early sixties according to a book telling the inside story of Watergate- Halderman tells of a death threat against Cuba's President and his brother- for which the reply was that the Kennedy boys would die- and they did! Sorry President Obama- That kind of Hollywood Movie will never be- Humour.. North Korea is the location where USA was defeated by China late Nov 1950. Likewise similar mountain country in Afghanistan has seen the end of five or maybe six major world empires and USA may have just joined that list- I do take locations seriously as a historian.

    ReplyDelete